20 Celebs Everyone Thinks Are Gay... But Are They?

The biggest sacrifice in becoming famous is the fact people will delve into all things personal, which includes sexual preference.

While being a celebrity comes with many rewards, it’s not always easy to live the life of constant fame. One of the biggest sacrifices in becoming famous is the fact that the world will continue to delve into all things personal, which includes sexual preference. The idea of having a private life is completely done away with and the new norm for a celebrity is trying hard to keep prying eyes at bay. One of the biggest sayings surrounding celebrities is that they haven’t achieved true fame until the gay rumors begin. The media loves to speculate on sexual preferences of their favorite stars and finding out a deep dark secret would be the scoop of the century. Hollywood has a history of celebrities living a double life in order to maintain popularity with the public and continue getting film roles. Rock Hudson is a great example of a heartthrob film star that hid his homosexuality in order to maintain his status as a film star.

Although homosexuality has become much more accepted in the eyes of filmmakers and the public, that doesn’t mean that all celebrities are willing to triumphantly come out of the closet. Sexuality has become a hugely complicated factor in the lives of celebrities since a lot has changed in the way the world views it. While it was once incredibly shaming and considered the end of a career, there have been a number of pioneers in the entertainment industry that have become hugely successful despite their homosexuality. In fact, those that have came out as gay or bisexual have received a ton of free publicity, which has led to increased career opportunities. Regardless, there are still many celebrities that remain ambiguous in their true nature and rumors have swirled for years. Check out our list of the 20 celebs everyone thinks are gay and see if you can tell which have been living truthfully or in deceit.

20 Drew Barrymore

When Drew Barrymore first transitioned out of the child actress phase, she went through a difficult time due to family problems and addiction issues. Yet, she was able to conquer those demons and emerged as one of Hollywood’s most beloved actresses. However, her wild ways and flower child persona didn’t seem suited to the conventional types of marriages. In fact, when she married Tom Green, the world started to look at it like it wasn’t a real relationship. In an interview with Contact Music, Barrymore stated that she had considered herself to be bisexual because “being with a woman is like exploring your own body but through someone else.” Later, she went on to marry and have children but the two ultimately divorced. This has made some wonder whether or not she was just using a traditional method as a way to have children and now she will finally settle down with a woman.

19 Tom Hardy

Tom Hardy is quickly being labeled Hollywood’s hottest new leading man after a string of hugely successful films and television appearances. From his role in Peaky Blinders to his latest hit, Taboo, it seems like Hardy can do no wrong in his acting choices. Yet, regardless of his success in his professional life, he couldn’t seem to escape the rumors surrounding his personal life. Early on in his career, Hardy gave an interview with Attitude and was asked if he ever had sexual relations with men. He responded with, “Of course I have. I’m an actor for f***’s sake. I’m an artist. I’ve played with everything and everyone.” He went on to backpedal the homosexual statements and snapped at a number of reporters that continued to press his sexuality as his professional career began to blossom. The rumors still persist, even though he is currently married with children.

18 Christina Aguilera

When Christina Aguilera was first introduced as the newest young pop star trying to make a name for herself in the music industry, she was seen as an incredible talent with a girl-next-door look. Yet, she soon transitioned from “Genie In A Bottle” to reveal her “Dirrty” side and the world began looking at her in a totally new light. There were also a number of media reports about Aguilera’s alleged tendency to call girls to join her and her then-husband in the VIP area of the nightclubs they would frequent. Aguilera revealed some intimate details about her relationship with her husband when she was asked onto The Ellen DeGeneres Show and even spoke about her love of walking around naked in her home. This new freaky side to Aguilera caused some to wonder about whether or not she was truly more into girls than males and while appearing as a judge on The Voice, Aguilera added to the rumors when she spontaneously kissed a female contestant.

17 Tila Tequila

Long before Instagram became the means for hot women everywhere to try and get their fifteen minutes of fame, Tila Tequila was the ultimate Internet girl to rise to fame. The public became entranced by this Asian beauty and it wasn’t long before MTV came calling to hand her a reality competition series entitled, A Shot At Love with Tila Tequila. Cashing in on her bisexual status, the contestants competing for her love were both male and female. Audiences often tuned in to see some steamy scenes that involved some major girl-on-girl action. The show became heavily criticized and even Tila made some accusations that the producers forced her to choose a man, even though she was more inclined towards the female contestant, Dani Campbell. There were times when she claimed she was no longer bisexual and identified as a lesbian. There was even an engagement to Casey Johnson before her untimely death. Yet, later she gave birth to a daughter with Thomas Whitaker.

16 Dakota Fanning

When Dakota Fanning was first introduced as a young actress, she captivated audiences in such films as Man on Fire and War of the Worlds. As she grew older, people couldn’t help but marvel at how beautiful she had become as the newest young “It” girl in Hollywood. However, there were soon rumors surrounding her sexuality and some reports that she had turned gay to be with Kristen Stewart. The two had become quite cozy after appearing together in several films and there were even reports that the two were married. However, those questionable photos and steamy film scenes may not be as telling as they seem. Fanning began publicly dating Jamie Strachan in 2013 and she’s never outright claimed that she was gay. With so many conflicting reports and questionable photos, it’s hard to say what the truth really is regarding Fanning’s sexuality.

15 Tom Cruise

Tom Cruise first gained popularity in the ‘80s but has managed to maintain his star quality over the years. He is still considered one of Hollywood’s most talented and successful leading men, despite some of the controversies within his personal life. There were a number of rumors surrounding his relationship to Nicole Kidman, with many believing that it was a staged marriage. After they divorced, people began speculating on his new romance with Katie Holmes. In an effort to prove how much he was truly in love with Holmes, Cruise appeared on The Oprah Winfrey Show and infamously jumped onto her couch professing his love for his new girlfriend. Many people thought this was a sign of deteriorating mental health and others thought it was major proof that he was trying to hide his true homosexual tendencies. Yet, Cruise has never owned up to being homosexual and will undoubtedly marry again.

14 Kourtney Kardashian

There was a lot of talk about how frigid Kourtney Kardashian was towards Scott Disick and it seemed like the only time she allowed him into her bed was when they were trying to make a baby. This only fueled the fire that Kourtney may not be interested in men at all and perhaps, she is actually gay. During the filming of Kourtney & Kim Take Miami, Kourtney made “friends” with a woman in her art class and the two became pretty friendly. This ultimately led to an outing to a gay nightclub where the two women shared an infamous kiss. The pair has stayed “friends” ever since but it doesn’t seem like they have a romantic relationship. The woman, Jackie Cruz, is actually best known for her role on Orange Is the New Black and has found success beyond being just the woman that showed the world that Kourtney Kardashian is open to a bit of fun with other women.

13 Cara Delevingne

When Cara Delevingne was featured in the September issue of Vogue UK in 2015, she had already been photographed a number of times being extra cozy with other women. Yet, it wasn’t until this Vogue feature that the world received true confirmation. However, it wasn’t so cut and dry as you’d think. The statements she made throughout the interview were far from standard when it comes to a celebrity revealing their sexuality and it caused many to question whether or not she was truly gay. When speaking about her girlfriend, Annie Clark, she stated, “I’m obviously in love, so if people want to say I’m gay, that’s great. But we’re all liquid – we change, we grow.” This made people think that she was treating her homosexual tendencies like it was a phase. She also said, “If I ever found a guy I could fall in love with, I’d want to marry him and have his children.”

12 Michelle Rodriguez

Michelle Rodriguez has made quite a successful career for herself playing the ultra tough females in male dominated films like the Fast & Furious franchise. While there was always a bit of speculation on her sexuality, she revealed the truth about her sexuality in an October 2013 interview with Entertainment Weekly. She acknowledged the fact that she is known for walking the red carpet solo and she hasn’t been open about her personal life in the past. Yet, she went on to say, “I’ve gone both ways. I do as I please. I am too f***ing curious to sit here and not try when I can. Men are intriguing. So are chicks.” When photographs began circulating of Rodriguez cozying up to Cara Delevingne, it seemed like she had finally made her choice. However, Cara’s sexuality has been rocky at best and it calls the tastes of Rodriguez into question.

11 Kristen Stewart

Kristen Stewart shot to international fame when she played the role of Bella Swan in the Twilight franchise but the true media scrutiny came when there were rumors surrounding her onscreen chemistry with Robert Pattinson. The two tried to keep their relationship out of the papers but it seemed to only fuel the public’s curiosity. Once they finally took their relationship out of the shadows, Stewart was caught cheating with her then-married director, Rupert Sanders. The media firestorm that came from the damning paparazzi photos created a major backlash on Stewart, who was painted as a cheater and homewrecker. It wasn’t too long after the release of the final Twilight film that Stewart went on SNL and came out as being gay. While she’s been photographed many times with various female girlfriends, her questionable past has led some to wonder whether or not she truly is gay or if she was trying to drastically change her persona and deflect from her past transgressions.

10 Amber Heard

Amber Heard was a budding actress and model in Hollywood but her career hadn’t yet gained speed. She was often seen with her girlfriend, Tasya van Ree, at various events and Heard was quite open about how truly they were committed to one another. However, all of that changed when Johnny Depp announced his split from his longtime girlfriend, Vanessa Paradis. Heard separated from her girlfriend and quickly became linked to Depp. The two were ultimately married but their wedded bliss was short-lived. Alarming reports came out regarding his aggressiveness while they were married and they ultimately called it quits. Heard was accused of using her relationship with Depp to try and propel her career and was also heavily criticized for the publicity she obtained from their tumultuous breakup. With so many questions coming from her ambition in achieving fame, it has made many wonder whether or not she was ever gay at all.

9 Anne Heche

Ellen DeGeneres is known as one of the most successful daytime talk show hosts of all time and has become a beloved celebrity in Hollywood. Yet, there was a time when her being openly gay wasn’t received very well by the general public. When her character revealed her sexuality on the TV sitcom, Ellen, the backlash was immense and the show ultimately came to an end. It actually took some time for the public (and Hollywood) to accept her back into the fold. Once she reemerged, she often walked the red carpet with Anne Heche by her side. At the time, Heche wasn’t well known by the general public as an actress but the increased media attention from dating Ellen DeGeneres was a great way for her to receive free publicity. The two wound up breaking up in 2000 and Heche later went on to marry the male actor, James Tupper.

8 Portia de Rossi

Portia de Rossi has had a number of different acting roles throughout her career but it wasn’t until her role as Nelle Porter in the hit TV series, Ally McBeal, that audiences sat up and took notice of this Aussie beauty. Once the series concluded in 2002, Rossi had difficulties getting a role that would e equally as successful and after awhile, people began to forget all about her as an actress. However, her name found its way back into the headlines once she began dating Ellen DeGeneres. Previously, she had never revealed that she was homosexual and it seemed like a big shock to see that not only was she gay but she was also dating Ellen DeGeneres. The two went on to get married (which was documented on TV) and then it was announced that the Aussie actress had just landed a role on the hit TV series, Scandal. Although her Scandal character was recently killed off the show, it did cause some people to wonder whether or not she is truly gay or she was just looking for a way to boost her career.

7 Ellen Page

Ellen Page is a hugely talented actress that is best known for her role in the Academy Award-winning film, Juno. Yet, she seemed to struggle a bit in achieving roles that were befitting her increased age. Everyone seemed to see her as the same high school-aged girl from the movie and she wasn’t receiving quality roles. While she did have a small role in the Leonardo DiCaprio film, Inception, it was a small part that didn’t seem to lead to any bigger and better roles. During her quest to become a full-on film star, she actually dated True Blood’s Alexander Skarsgård for quite some time. However, even that didn’t seem to increase her celebrity status and it wasn’t until Page came out at the Human Rights Campaign’s Time To THRIVE conference that she really started receiving major media attention.

6 Nelly Furtado

Nelly Furtado first gained fame in the early 2000s when her debut studio album, Whoa, Nelly!, was released to a rave review. Audiences fell in love with her fresh new sound and she had a string of hit singles that quickly helped her star to rise. However, there was a lot of chatter about her sexuality and it caused many to wonder whether or not she was heterosexual. In an effort to try and get a final answer, once and for all, Furtado was interviewed by Blender magazine in 2005. When asked if she was attracted to women, Furtado replied, “Absolutely. Women are beautiful and sexy.” Since she had been previously linked to men, including the father of her daughter, many thought that her statement solidified that she was actually bisexual. However, Furtado later backpedaled and even went on to marry a man, Demacio Castellon.

5 Sandra Bernhard

Sandra Bernhard is a female comedian and actress that got her start in the late 1970s. Yet, she is probably best known for her role as Nancy Bartlett on the hit TV sitcom, Roseanne. Playing Tom Arnold’s girlfriend on the series, the two didn’t exactly seem to have a true romantic connection as supporting characters on the show. Many people started to question Bernhard’s sexuality and she later became a huge supporter of gay rights. Bernhard claimed to identify as bisexual, even though she had a daughter in 1998 with a man. Nowadays, she seems to have settled down with the famed writer and producer, Sara Switzer. The two raise Bernhard’s daughter together and are often photographed at various red carpet events on one another’s arm.

4 Joseline Hernandez

As the self-crowned “Puerto Rican Princess” of Love & Hip Hop: Atlanta, Joseline Hernandez has made quite a name for herself. She has quickly become a favorite on the series and the drama involving her relationship with Stevie J has offered an entertaining storyline for this former stripper. While the two are now at odds after the birth of their child together, there have been numerous reports that say that there were other females entwined with the couple for the entire time they were together. A woman came forward and said that she was in a three-way relationship with Hernandez and Stevie J while they were dating. Hernandez ultimately addressed the rumors and claimed that she was bisexual and that she “was gay.” When Hernandez was asked to address the rumors surrounding the breakup between her and Stevie J on The Wendy Williams Show, fans later addressed the fact that it seemed like Hernandez was hitting on the female talk show host during her appearance.

3 Maria Bello

While Maria Bello hasn’t quite created a name for herself as big as Angelina Jolie as an actress in Hollywood, there is no doubt that audiences will recognize her face from one of the many different roles she’s taken over the years. From her returning character on ER to her memorable character in Coyote Ugly, Bello is one of those rare talents that seem to be in a number of different TV and film roles without all of the worldwide fame of some of the other celebrities. After living a veritable lifetime as a straight woman, Bello wrote a piece for The New York Times entitled, “Coming Out As A Modern Family.” She detailed how her 12-year-old son actually asked her whether or not she had a girlfriend and that was when she wound up telling him that her longtime friend and Godmother to him was actually someone that she was having a romantic relationship with.

2 Erin Daniels

When the Showtime series, The L Word, first debuted in 2004, there was an instant fascination with the characters and the different relationships featured in the series. Because the show featured a number of unknown actresses, the steamy scenes between these women caused a lot of speculation amongst audiences as to whether or not these women were truly lesbians. The acting on the series seemed well enough but it was the amount of girl-on-girl action that caused many to think that there must be some sort of feeling there in order to create such passionate scenes. In actuality, Kate Moennig and Leisha Hailey were the only actresses on the series that were actually identifying as homosexual and Erin Daniels was very much heterosexual. She has gone on to marry and have children and she looks back on her time with The L Word fondly.

1 John Travolta

There was a time when John Travolta was thought of as one of the most handsome and eligible men in Hollywood. His iconic roles in Saturday Night Fever and Grease allowed him to become one of Hollywood’s hottest heartthrobs. When he was married to Kelly Preston, it seemed like he had finally found someone he could settle down with. The two seemed like the perfect couple, attending every red carpet event and had beautiful children together. Yet, a series of reports regarding Travolta’s sexuality have caused many people to question whether or not he was truly heterosexual. From multiple claims from former masseuses to rumors surrounding his copilot for his private plane, it’s hard to deny each of all the claims that have come through regarding Travolta’s sexuality.

Sources: Vogue, Daily Mail, Entertainment Weekly

Give TheRichest a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheRichest?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in Entertainment

20 Celebs Everyone Thinks Are Gay... But Are They?