15 Insane Catfish Stories That'll Change Your Mind About Online Dating

Online dating apps and social media sites are taking over social interactions, discouraging people from communicating face-to-face, as it’s easier to take rejection when it’s through some kind of online platform. The downside of this is that online users with certain  profiles are a hundred times more likely to be "Catfished." So, what’s Catfishing, you ask? A term made popular by MTV’s show Catfish, this is when someone creates a dating or social media profile using someone else’s photos in order to deceive others.

If you’ve seen the show then you know Nev and Max travel around the country investigating online relationships suspected to have formed from fake profiles. While Catfishers often go after their victims to boost their own self-confidence, some stories aren’t so simple. They might be scammers who are out for money, an ex seeking revenge, or someone who is just plain bored. Catfish highlights both sides of Catfishing, and has inspired hundreds of people to come forward with their own stories.

Both victims and Catfishers themselves have shared their experiences all over the internet, and not all of them are quite as PG as those on the show. Think you’re safe? Even those who don’t go out of their way to seek relationships online can become a victim of Catfishing simply by having a profile on any social media website. Even private profiles allow "friends" to access your photos, and there are no regulations on what they can and cannot do with them. Not worried? You will be after you read these insane Catfish stories! In fact, I guarantee that you’ll be deactivating profiles left and right by the end of this article.

15 The Alyssa Milano Not-So-Look-Alike


Reddit user doghound412 described his experience on Plenty of Fish as uneventful until he finally connected with a sexy Alyssa Milano look-alike. Even though he noticed that her photos had been touched-up and described them as “1980’s Glamour Shots,” he decided to give it a shot and drove thirty miles to meet her face-to-face. After heading to a Starbucks close to where she lived in the pouring rain, he peeked inside and immediately assumed he’d been stood up. “As I approach the door I notice there being very few people [inside]… an older bald male, a very tall chubby cleaning lady, a teen mom and her child, and a few employees.”

Since you know where this is heading, can you guess which one was his date? It was the chubby cleaning lady, who turned out to be a fish most people would throw back rather than the Milano look-alike she claimed to be in her photos. “We talked (I listened) for about 5 whole minutes about how she lost custody of her child, she was in rehab and on disability, and was basically living in a friend's basement. I humored the situation and asked what she liked to do when she got loud and said she just LOOOOOVED people watching and proceed to make fun of everyone in the shop loudly for 10 minutes.”

Sounds bad, right? Well, it gets worse. The guy made it through his cup of coffee and politely made up an excuse to leave, claiming he needed to get to bed early for work the next morning. In attempt to save the evening, he decided to stop at an Ikea nearby since he’d already made the long-distance drive.

14 The Sims Gone Wild

Remember playing Sims as a kid and connecting with other kids through the game? It was like being in a chatroom that depicted real-life interactions. Reddit user dank4tao described how he met a girl named “Chloe” while playing the game, and quickly developed a long distance relationship with her. Then, as all teenagers do, he asked Chloe if she had a friend that he could set his best friend up with, and coincidentally she did!

After years of the two being in long-distance relationships, they decided they would fly to California to meet the girls they’d been talking to. Unfortunately for this Reddit user, Chloe was unable to meet him as she was preparing to move to Massachusetts. This didn’t stop his friend from flying out to meet his online girlfriend, however.

13 Catfish Prevents Murder

When nineteen-year-old Marissa Williams pissed off her aunt by inviting strange guys she’d met online to their home, her aunt decided to teach her a lesson. As Marissa’s caregiver, her aunt chose to create a fake Facebook profile to show her niece the dangers of having online relationships, but instead was shown a side of her niece that shocked her.

Under the identity Tre “Topdog” Ellis, Marissa’s aunt friended her niece and began chatting with her on a regular basis. It wasn’t long before her niece gave the stranger her phone number and home address, inviting him to come over and get drunk with her. Marissa even went as far as offering to have sex with “Tre” if he’d pay her $50 cell phone bill.

12 Catfished By Yourself


Imagine you’re scrolling through potential dates or hook ups on your favorite dating app and you come across yourself. This is exactly what happened to Jack Kennedy as he was swiping through guys on Grindr. Jack received an initial message of just a photo of himself, and assuming the guy was asking if that was him in the picture he responded, “Mhm?” and asked for the guy to send him photos of himself. To his surprise, the guy continued to send him picture after picture depicting himself. Jack confronted the Catfish, telling him that he was sending him photos of himself, but they wouldn’t admit their lie and even offered Jack proof.

"They started sending more photos of me, and I was just sat in bed thinking 'OK, this guy has to be joking. There's no way this is happening.' Then he actually offered to send proof that it was him, and at this point I just couldn't stop laughing. I went on to ask him for his 'proof', which turned out to be a photo of his (fortunately not mine) penis. After this I just closed the app and ignored him."

11 'Doc' Catfishes Woman Into Lesbian Relationship


Angela Buchanan had been pursuing a relationship with a female friend for years with little progress until she posed as a gynecologist on Yahoo! with the username “Doc.” Buchanan recommended this “doctor” to her long-time friend, claiming she had helped her with her battle against breast cancer and the delivery of her twins that she’d had through in vitro fertilization with a previous partner. Confused yet? Stay with me, the facts get even more jumbled...

Posing as “Doc,” Angela began a professional relationship online with her crush, pretending to let her in on Angela’s cancer diagnosis. She informed her Catfishing victim that in order to ward off Angela’s cancer, she should encourage Angela to get into a sexual relationship to release helpful hormones. The "Doc" even suggested the victim herself lend her friend a hand. While the victim had grown up gay, she hadn’t identified as a lesbian for years due to moral reasons. However, to save her friend, she reluctantly agreed to a sexual relationship with Angela.

The scam gets worse. Every week, Angela would supposedly go for bloodwork, and “Doc” would later go over the results with her victim to demonstrate to her how their intimacy was improving Angela’s health and recommend how their sexual relationship should continue. “Doc” would advise her of the length of time, frequency, and nature of the sex she should have with Angela each week. Even more sickening, Angela told her that “Doc” recommended she get ahead of the cancer and receive a mastectomy, and on the day of the surgery, like any good friend, the victim was by her side.

10 Kidd Cole Catfishes His Way To Celebrity Status


Claiming to have been the youngest artist under Kanye West’s record label, you may be familiar with Kidd Cole if you’re a fan of MTV’s Catfish. Probably the most manipulative Catfish in the show’s history, Nev and Max are first introduced to his persona by a woman named Lucille, who was under the impression that she was working for Kidd Cole as an assistant. She was originally contacted by the self-proclaimed rapper on Twitter, and he offered her a trial run for a position within the company. As it had always been Lucille’s dream to work in the music industry, she was excited to help and jumped at the opportunity.

Her trial run consisted of arranging a security team, hotels, and a driver for the alleged artist for a performance he had in Washington D.C. Instead of paying these invoices, Kidd Cole created a series of fake contracts, and Lucille was inevitably responsible for paying his debts of thousands of dollars.

After Nev and Max did some digging, they discovered that both the artist’s and his manager’s phone numbers were registered by the same person. Additionally they used their connections at MTV to discover that no one at Kanye West’s record label had heard of him, and that the MTV artist page that he used to validate his up and coming celebrity status was nothing more than a glorified MySpace page. Even the tracks on his music page were stolen from other artists.

9 Football Player Catfished


One of the more well known cases of Catfishing happened to Notre Dame football player Manti Te’o in 2012. When his girlfriend Lennay Kekua succumbed to leukemia, there was an outpouring of support from fans. Even though her death inspired the linebacker to play better, inevitably leading the team to the BCS National Championship game, it turned out the player had been Catfished.

When the story broke, the media did some digging and discovered that his alleged girlfriend Lennay Kekua did not actually exist. After Manti received a phone call from Lennay’s phone number and the voice he recognized as hers on the other end claimed that she was in fact alive, the school decided to launch a full investigation on the issue. The trail led them to the real woman in the photographs who provided the name of someone who likely created the profile. Claims came out that Manti knew about the fake Twitter profile, and that he was using the death of his online girlfriend for publicity.

8 Catfish Causes Teenager’s Suicide


Probably one of the most controversial Catfishing incidents in history, Lori Drew’s decision to create a fake MySpace page has inspired controversy among lawmakers all over the country. In attempt to defend her teenage daughter against a bully, she created a fake MySpace profile under the name Josh Evans. Posing as a 16-year-old boy, Lori attacked her daughter’s bully through use of personal messages, even having a coworker contribute to the nasty conversation. No one can say which of the two women sent the last message telling the teenager that the world would be better off without her, but it fell harshly on the 13-year-old who hung herself in her bedroom just twenty minutes after the message was sent.

7 Birdman Nearly Gets Locked Up


Chris “Birdman” Anderson is another athlete who was the victim of Catfishing. Shelley Chartier, a 31-year-old Canadian recluse, had created over a dozen fake Facebook profiles for celebrities- including the NBA player. Shelley used the profiles to lure underage girls into conversations with her, and she’d then pose as the girls and forward the conversations along to the actual celebrities. Unfortunately for Birdman, he agreed to meet up with one of these girls as he’d been talking to Shelley the whole time who had told the athlete that the girl was nineteen.

6 Teenager Dies After Catfish Cancels Date


I think we can all agree that there’s nothing like falling in love as a teenager, and with the popularity of online dating sites these days, the chances of becoming Catfished have increased drastically. Brandon Wentzell was unknowingly the victim of someone he met on Plenty of Fish who didn’t only catfish him once, but created a slew of characters each with their own social media pages and personalities.

It started with Clarissa, with whom Brendan quickly developed a relationship and fell in love. Clarissa then introduced him to her brother, who she said was Brendan’s age. It wasn’t long before the two were online buddies as well. To add further drama to the mix, Clarissa’s jealous ex-boyfriend would send Brandon threatening messages on Facebook that would often rile him up, according to his mother. Unfortunately, Brendon didn’t realize these three Facebook profiles were actually being run by a single person, a woman he didn't actually know at all.

5 A Shocking Catfish Ending


As a fan of MTV’s Catfish, it would be impossible for me to leave out one of my favorite episodes. In the premiere of season four, Nev and Max meet 21-year-old Tiana who is head-over-heels for a guy named James. The two met on Myspace three years earlier, and hit it off. Even though they only lived 45 minutes from each other, it seemed Tiana only became suspicious after years of canceled meetings and failed video chats. Hilariously, throughout the episode Tiana mixed up Nev and Max several times, to which they played along, of course.

While Tiana was sure that James was hiding something from her, it became known that she was hiding something from him also. Apparently James had made it clear that he was opposed to a life with children, so Tiana had hid from him the fact that she had a daughter, which turned out to be nothing compared to what he was hiding.

4 Catfish Preys On Teenagers


Natalia Burgess, a 29-year-old woman, was sentenced to over two years in prison for luring teenage boys as young as 13 into online relationships and getting them to send her money. She would convince these boys to give her their Facebook login information so she could change their relationship status to a "in a relationship" with her. Natalia would then ask them for their banking information, claiming she wanted to lend them money so they could add minutes to their phone plan and they could talk more. It’s easy to see how a young guy with raging hormones would fall for this, especially when they think they’re talking to some sexy, older woman.

3 Mother Of The Year


The mother of Reddit user 'Mommasaur' should be put away for child endangerment. She explained that her and her sister had become suspicious of their mother’s behavior, and thought she might be involved in Catfishing men on Facebook. “My mother had asked my sister one time how to make multiple Facebook accounts, would close her laptop whenever you entered the room, kept tape over the camera on the computer, and her phone would ring all the time, but she would never answer it.”

2 Catfished By A Ghost


Reddit user Arhia posted about her relationship on MSN as a teenager with 'Zack.' They continued their friendship for nearly two years without ever meeting in person or video chatting. Zack told her all about his sister and his mother, and even about his father who had left them when he was a child. They talked on a regular basis, until he came online and she noticed that he was a bit off. Then he asked that they video chat, which she found odd since they’d never done that before.

“So webcam turns on and there’s this girl. She looked about 14…I had been talking to 'her' the whole time. Except I hadn’t at the same time. Zack died a few years back. When he died (I have no idea what had happened to him) his little sister took on his personality…She believed she was Zack a lot of the time. Spoke like she was him, told people she was him. So the whole time I had been talking to a personality of a mentally ill girl.”

1 Catfish Vigilante Or Trained Actor


Back to MTV’s Catfish, another one of my favorite episodes depicted a cheating baby daddy and an online dating vigilante seemingly off his rocker. If you’re a fan of the show, there’s no way you don’t remember Artis. After developing an online relationship with “Jess,” Artis was compelled to put things on hold with his baby mama and live-in girlfriend to pursue this mystery girl. Turned out, the only photo Artis had ever seen of this girl was taken from an adult site, cropped appropriately.

Still convinced he and Jess had something special, Nev and Max set up a meeting between the two. I think it’s safe to say that viewers around the world were in shock when they saw Justin step out of his car and approach the cameras. Supposed strangers, Justin claimed to be a vigilante targeting men in relationships with his fake Facebook page. By luring men away from their girlfriends, he felt like he was teaching them a lesson when he stood them up or came forward as himself.

The world was in shock, as Justin’s persona was intense to say the least and the media took to investigate his backstory. Rumors that Justin and Artis knew each other and that the whole thing was an act hit Twitter soon after the episode aired. Whether they pulled one over the eyes of Catfish’s producers, Jerry Springer style, or whether the show hires actors is unknown, but it sure did make for a great episode!

Sources:  nzherald, inquisitr , reddit

Give TheRichest a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheRichest?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in Most Shocking

15 Insane Catfish Stories That'll Change Your Mind About Online Dating