23 Hollywood Actors Who Suffer From The Co-Star Curse

'Oh it's that guy / girl! I LOVE them! What else do I know them from...?'

A typical response when one of these familiar actors appear on screen; we know and even love their faces, we know they can make a good movie better, but we can rarely remember their names.

It's a tale as old as Hollywood; as long as there are commanding leading men and prepossessing leading ladies, there will be talented supporting actors who allow the stars to shine. In fact, a great many of these smaller-name actors have forged long, lucrative and award-winning (if not particularly glittering) careers by consistently playing supporting or 'character' roles. In most cases these actors' unrelenting supporting positions don't mean they're any less talented than the A-listers. On the contrary, their ability to adapt, to diversify, and to become those comfortingly familiar mainstays in Hollywood speak to their supreme talent.

The dynamic of an ensemble cast can make or break the success of a movie and that’s exactly why these supporting actors deserve recognition in their own right. If the movie industry can do it with an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor, we figure we can too. These are 23 of the actors who have held Hollywood together for decades, but never quite get the recognition they deserve...

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

23 Peter MacNicol

You will certainly recognize MacNicol, and you'll likely have lots of warm and fuzzy feelings for this actor - but can you mention one movie or TV show in which he appeared? Go on, it's on the tip of your tongue..

OK, we'll help you out. You probably know MacNicol from several standout roles in, for example, comedy classics like 1995's Dracula: Dead and Loving It, the Addams Family Values, or Ghostbusters II, and TV shows like Ally McBeal and, more recently, Greys Anatomy and Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. MacNicol has been working consistently as both actor and voice artist since the early '90s: Despite his 60 years, he has maintained his distinctive loveable, youthful look through the course of his long and very active career. But he's always been more of a character actor, and never quite fitted the bill for Leading Man.

22 Kathy Najimy

21 Allison Janney

55 year old Allison Janney has been acting since the early 1990s. She has had a very long and reputable career as a stage, television and film actress. Despite Emmy awards, Screen Actors Guild awards and even Tony award nominations, Boston born Janney has  never played the leading lady role. Regardless, she is very well respected and is most recently notable for her supporting work in The West Wing and Masters of Sex.

20 Embeth Davidtz

Embeth Davidtz rose to stardom partly thanks to her role as the sweetheart teacher in Matilda. She had supporting roles with Robin Williams in Bicentennial Man and a notable supporting turn in Bridget Jones' Diary. Despite never having landed the role of leading lady, she's had a prolific career - and she even appeared as Mary Parker in 2014's The Amazing Spider-Man 2. Her TV credits include Grey's Anatomy and Mad Men.

19 Dylan Baker

You might remember David Baker in Spider-Man 2 and 3 as Dr. Curt Connors. Baker has played in dozens of memorable supporting roles with leading actors including Denzel Washington, Will Ferrell, and Leonardo DiCaprio. Despite his work as a secondary actor, there are no signs of his career waning anytime soon; he has at least two films in post-production to be released in 2015.

18 Bill Nighy

Bill Nighy is an award-winning British character actor, and one of the most well-loved of the British screen veterans. Nighy got his start in Guildford School of Dance and Drama in London, and is well known to international audiences for his role as a washed-up rock star in Love, Actually and as Rufus Scrimgeour in the Harry Potter series. He has been acting professionally since 1979 and has continued to take roles in leading international and American films. He won a BAFTA award for Best Supporting Actor.

17 Bob Balaban

69 year old Bob Balaban is one of those instantly recognizable faces who seems to have been around forever without ever having changed much. Throughout the course of his varied and prolific career, he has held supporting roles in - among others - Close Encounters of the Third Kind, Moonrise Kingdom, A Mighty Wind, and The Grand Budapest Hotel. Although he has won a 1979 Tony Award for Best Actor for his work on the stage, he has not quite broken out into leading film roles.

16 Octavia Spencer

15 Mary Kay Place

Mary Kay Place, 67, has co-starred with big name stars like Reese Witherspoon, John Cusack and Meryl Streep. She is one of the most well-established supporting actors in Hollywood, having been acting since as far back as 1976 when she got her breakthrough role as the country-western singer Loretta Haggers in TV’s Mary Hartman, Mary Hartman. Her upcoming roles in 2015 will be in movies The Hollars and Grace and Frankie.

14 Margo Martindale

Margo Martindale can do it all as a supporting and character actor, including both comedy and drama, television and movies. Recently she co-starred in August: Osage County with Julia Roberts and Meryl Streep, and in 2007, with John C. Reilly in the comedy Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story. She won a Primetime Emmy Award in 2011 for Outstanding Supporting Actress and has been nominated for many others.

13 Christine Taylor

12 Jonathan Loughran

Via pastebin.com

If you're an Adam Sandler fan, than you have undoubtedly seen the cross-eyed comedic look of Jonathan Loughran. He may be Sandler’s first choice for a supporting actor, but he has broke away on his own with small supporting roles in two Kill Bill movies and Get Smart. He has no award nominations yet, and his movie choices don't seem to have moved in the direction of critical acclaim, but given that Sandler likes to cast his buddies we can safely bet that Loughran's career will go on for as long as that of his more famous friend.

11 Peter Dante

Via .hotflick.net

Peter Dante is another Adam Sandler favourite, appearing in some capacity in almost every Happy Madison production in the last decade - but he hasn't ever ventured further outside of that realm of relatively low-grade humour. He may only have supporting roles in the Sandler films, but he always strives to hit the mark and get laughs, playing any character is thrown at him from a gay lawyer to a macho police officer.

10 Judy Greer

Michigan-born Judy Greer is the eternal best friend, who has held supporting roles for most of her career. Since she began appearing on screen in the late '90s, Greer has amassed over 50 screen credits to her name.

In the last five years, however, she has been breaking out with larger and larger roles alongside major actors including George Clooney and Clive Owen. People can expect a lot more of her with her starring roles in the highly anticipated movies Jurassic World and Disney’s Tomorrowland. 

In 2014, Greer published a book of autobiographical essays, Confessions of a Co-Star, a title which indicates a definite level of commitment to - or at least, recognition of - her status as the always-supporting actor.

9 Hugo Weaving

Hugo Weaving has had some high-profile roles, but rarely do we see him as a leading man. One exception is V for Vendetta with Natalie Portman, but his face was covered the entire film with the iconic Guy Fawkes mask. Regardless, he has done nothing less than impress audiences with his work in The Matrix Trilogy and The Lord of the Rings.

8 Joan Cusack

7 Chris Cooper

6 Vincent D’Onofrio

Vincent D’Onofrio is one of the privileged few who worked with Stanley Kubrick in the masterpiece Full Metal Jacket. He played Private Gomer Pyle who eventually couldn’t handle the stress caused by the abusive Drill Sergeant. His career has been strong since then, appearing in dozens of films, most recently The Judge with Robert Downey Jr. D’Onofrio will be seen as Morton in the next installment of the Jurassic Park franchise.

5 John Goodman

4 Rob Riggle

3 Luis Guzman

In his long career since the 1970s, Luis Guzman has appeared in over 50 feature films and television series, but has never starred as a leading actor in any of them. He has worked with critically-acclaimed directors Paul Thomas Anderson and costarred with dozens of A-list actors including Jim Carrey and Jennifer Connelly.

2 Peter Dinklage

1 Paul Giamatti

Paul Giamatti had supporting roles for years before finally becoming the leading actor in the last 5 years. Some of his most breakout performances include Barney’s Version and the independent film Win Win. He is often critically acclaimed for his performances, even as a supporting actor. This can be seen in 12 Years a Slave and Saving Mr. Banks. He was nominated in 2006 for an Oscar for Best Actor in a Supporting Role, but did not win. However, it’s likely only a matter before he earns the coveted Oscar for Best Actor.

More in Entertainment