1. American Caramel Urban Faber White Sox Baseball Card, $1,378,048.41
Urban ‘Red’ Faber spent 19 years playing as a pitcher for his beloved Chicago White Sox. Despite pitching for one of the weakest teams in the league, Faber’s impressive talent was apparent to everyone watching. He was, deservedly, inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1964, 31 years after his retirement.
While far from being a household name, Faber’s baseball cards have inexplicably risen in value exponentially in recent years. So much so, his 1922 baseball card is currently the most expensive item listed on Amazon.